Brand Marketing Search Engine

Sunday, November 05, 2006

Extension brand failures: Harley Davidson perfume

The sweet smell of failure

In various magazines, at various conferences, and in his online newsletter, Saatchi and Saatchi’s worldwide chief executive officer, Kevin Roberts, has talked of the ‘mythology of the brand’. The most powerful brands, according to Roberts, are those that have built their own mythology, or rather, that have helped their loyal customers to build this mythology. The one brand with perhaps more mythology attached to it than any other is, without doubt, Harley Davidson.

Harley Davidson owners aren’t just loyal. They love the brand. They do not care that the motorcycles they ride are not the best in terms of technology or that they may be prone to the occasional oil leakage. What matters is the biker myth – the freedom of the open road, and all its macho connotations.

This myth is vividly conjured up in the book Hell’s Angel: The Life and Times of Sonny Barger and The Hell’s Angels Motorcycle Club by Sonny Barger (the original Hell’s Angel). In a chapter entitled, ‘Harleys, Choppers, Full Dressers and Stolen Wheels,’ Barger writes:

What it’s really about with a Harley Davidson is the sound ... everybody loves that rumble. Another thing Harley owners really crave about their bikes is the low-end torque, the raw power coming out of the gate.

It runs out pretty quick once you get up past ninety miles an hour. Most Harley riders don’t care about high speed, they’d rather have that lowend torque, the one that gurgles down in your groin and gives you the feeling of power. The Japanese bikes, while they have the power, they don’t quite have the feeling of power.

The appeal of the Harley Davidson is essentially masculine and its customers take brand loyalty to extreme levels. Indeed, many testosterone-charged Harley owners even tattoo the Harley Davidson name and imagery onto their bodies.

The company has attempted to capitalize on this unique strength of feeling towards the brand, by pushing the Harley Davidson chain of shops selling a wide variety of branded merchandise – Harley Davidson T-shirts, socks, cigarette lighters and ornaments. While Harley Davidson’s core fans may have accused the company of ‘Disneyfying’ the brand, the real problem occurred when Harley Davidson attached its name to a range of aftershave and perfume. For lovers of the motorcycle, this was an extension too far.

Harley Davidson had fallen into the trap of thinking that more products equals more sales. And it usually does, at least in the short term. But as Al and Laura Ries write in The 22 Immutable Laws of Branding, this type of strategy can have negative consequences in the long term:

Do you build the brand today in order to move merchandise tomorrow?

Or do you expand the brand today in order to move the goods today and see it decline tomorrow? [...]

Line extension, megabranding, variable pricing and a host of other sophisticated marketing techniques are being used to milk brands rather than build them. While milking may bring in easy money in the short term, in the long term it wears down the brand until it no longer stands for anything.

Ironically, though, this quest for more products and to broaden the Harley Davidson line went against the way the company had built the brand in the first place. In Hell’s Angel, Barger writes:

Harley has enjoyed a huge share of the large bike market for decades. They control about fifty percent of cruiser sales, with Japanese bikes making up the other half. As a result, they often act a little high and mighty toward their customers.

An official at Harley Davidson was once quoted as saying, ‘Enough bikes is too many, and if we make enough, we lose mystique.’ While they keep saying they’re building more and more each year, up until a couple of years ago I believe Harley Davidson intentionally held back production to stir up demand.

The implication is that Harley Davidson originally understood that its customers could have too much of a good thing. Not only had it stayed focused on motorbikes, but the company may have also limited their availability in order to generate the Harley Davidson ‘mystique’.

By the 1990s, however, the brand was clearly heading in the other direction. Alongside aftershave and perfume, the company also launched Harley Davidson wine coolers. As you would expect, the bikers were not impressed.

On her Internet homepage, one biker girl, who calls herself ‘Tinker’, recounted her experience of seeing all these inappropriate items on sale in a Harley Davidson chain store:

Drifting closer, I found myself dazzled by the seemingly infinite variety of stuff. Man, they had everything under the sun! There were H-D socks, perfumes, infant clothes, an entire line of kids wear, tons of ornaments and collectables, even ties, all stamped with the official HD license logo. Everything, from the truly nice to the frankly ugly, was on display. Everything that is except an actual Harley Davidson motorcycle.

No parts, even. There was a Buell [a Harley Davidson model] in the window, with a ‘Do Not Touch’ sign on it.

A salesperson wandered over. ‘Can I help you find something?’ she asked brightly.

Sure,’ I said. ‘Have you got the official licensed Harley Davidson shampoo?

Shampoo?’ she asked, a little uncertain.

Oh absolutely,’ I said. ‘It looks and smells just like motor oil, but it makes my hair so manageable!’ I smiled as I made my escape, but I know it’s just a matter of time.

Tinker was not alone in her criticism. And pretty soon, it became clear that the motorcycle giant was alienating its core customers.

Harley Davidson values are strong, masculine, very rugged values,’ says Charles E Brymer, chief executive officer of the Interbrand Group, a branding consultancy based in New York. ‘For Harley Davidson to go into a sector that doesn’t live up to what those values are would be disastrous.’

However, the disaster was a relatively limited one. The company has now admitted its mistake, and stopped producing perfumes and other inappropriate products.

In an interview for The Business Knowledge Network, Joe Nice, the director of corporate communications for Harley Davidson, spoke candidly of the company’s branding failures. ‘Over the years,’ he said, ‘we’re tried a number of different approaches to merchandising and put the Harley Davidson brand on some things that, in retrospect, we may not have been well-advised to do.

The company is much more selective today about who we work with and how we go about extending the brand.’

Lessons from Harley Davidson

  • Focus on your brand values. If your values are ‘strong, masculine and very rugged,’ you shouldn’t be selling perfume or wine coolers. A range of baby clothes may also be a bad idea.
  • Don’t alienate your core customers. For brands that inspire strong loyalty, the temptation is to test that loyalty to its limits by stretching the brand into other product categories. However, this is a dangerous strategy and can lead to what marketing experts refer to as ‘brand dilution’ – in other words, a watered-down brand.
  • Remember that more is less. ‘When you study categories over a long period, you can see that adding more can weaken growth, not help it,’ writes Jack Trout in his book, Big Brands, Big Trouble: Lessons Learned the Hard Way.
  • ‘The more you add, the more you risk undermining your basic differentiating idea, which is the essence of your brand.’
  • Keep it tight. Harley Davidson built its brands by staying true to what it does best, namely making big, classic, US motorbikes. The further it moved away from this original focus, the further it got into trouble. Any brand which attempts to be a ‘Jack of all trades’ will ultimately fail to carve a strong identity in any category.
  • Handle ‘lovemarks’ with care. According to advertising guru Kevin Roberts, truly successful brands don’t have ‘trademarks’. They have ‘lovemarks’. In a now famous article for Fast Company magazine’s September 2000 issue, Roberts cited Harley Davidson as a supreme example of a lovemark and commended the company for not following the marketing rulebook.

Although Roberts says that the motorbikes themselves are ‘actually pretty average’, the nature of the brand has meant that the motorbikes don’t have to be compared to others in terms of performance. Roberts says: As a lovemark, Harley Davidson has two things. One is its signature rumbling sound. The other is that you can’t go very fast on a Harley, so you have to ride in a pack [. . .] The mystery of the Harley isn’t in its performance, and it isn’t in any of the words that end in ‘er’. Most brands are built on ‘er’ words – faster, bigger, better, cleaner. Mystery doesn’t need those words. Mystery also doesn’t need hundreds of themed stores to push its brand extensions. In fact, such an approach tends to erode the mystery altogether.


markdude said...

So...anyone know what a full HD wine cooler might be worth?

prathamesh said...

Yeah, even i am eager to know. How much did it cost?

cowgirl said...

did you ever find out what they are worth? I have a 4 set of them unopened? Have had them for 20+ yrs. Going to put them on EBay.

John Petter said...

I am happy to found this blog.. Adrienne Vittadini

DSL Express said...

Hey!!! Nice Stuff. I use the scents and noticed that if I rub some on the inside of my shirt or sweater, the scent really lasts. I usually just take a dab and rub it in my hands and then 'wipe' it off on my jeans, my shirts, etc. I do this in addition to putting it directly on my skin on the pulse points. I love the perfumes and deodorants! To purchase online best perfume for men, Gift sets, Dryfurits and many more and women in india visit our online Store Drag2Kart.Com

best perfumes for women in india | best perfume for women in india | best perfume for women in india | branded perfumes for women in india | best perfumes for women india | perfumes for women in india with price | buy perfumes online india | best deo for men | best perfumes for men in india | online shopping for perfumes | best deodorant for men in india | online shopping for deodorants | buy gift sets online india | baby gift sets online.

Official said...

Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. ibcbet, judi bola, sbobet, agen bola terpercaya, ibcbet, agen bola

Unknown said...

Thanks .i want to buy some perfume brand good and high quality - nước hoa ô tô - nước hoa ô tô nhập khẩu hương thơm gia đình
khử mùi ô tônước hoa ô tô nhật

JannethManalu said...

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know

Poker Online

filtergatan said...

thx for share n u can see my web pages, maybe good for u


Agen Judi Online

thx before

situs agen judi online sbobet bola casino indonesia terpercaya said...

situs judi online asia.

idn poker

Kumpulan judi online

JannethManalu said...

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know

Idn Poker Terbaik Deposit 25rb

Kumpulan Artikel Poker Online Terbaru 2019 said...

Hello my name is Mirai Yu.. i like your post and i think this interisting.. i want tell a little about my hobby is Shopping, Photo Shooting and singging. and if u want know more about me, u can visit my Offocial Website :D

IDN Poker

Berita Olahraga said...

Game IDN Poker Online tentu telah dikenal seluruh orang. Permainan yang begitu seru ini jadi semakin gampang untuk diakses dan dapat dimainkan melawan semua orang di dunia. Yang tidak sedikit orang tidak ketahui ialah sekarang ini telah ada poker online yang mempunyai sifat perjudian, dimana masing-masing pemain bertaruh murni memakai uang asli. Bahkan website seperti tersebut sangat tidak sedikit di Indonesia ini. Karena walaupun pemerintah sudah melarang, namun pemerintah tidak bisa melakukan apa-apa, kenapa?

situs agen judi online sbobet bola casino indonesia terpercaya said...

tentunya jika kita ingin menang besar dalam game online perjudian Anda akan dapat membuka pintu sukses besar menggunakan beberapa jurus ampuh antara lain adalah:
Pilih jenis permainan dikendalikan perjudian online
Bahkan, saat ini ada banyak bentuk permainan judi pokerqq online kita bisa bermain dengan baik dan menikmati. Dengan berbagai bentuk perjudian online, maka kita harus memilih bentuk permainan yang dapat menghasilkan kemenangan besar yang bentuk permainan kami tahu dengan baik bagaimana bermain dan juga pelaksanaan strategi. Dengan demikian kita dapat menjadi kesempatan besar untuk berhasil dan menang dalam jumlah besar karena mereka benar-benar memahami strategi yang dikreditkan dengan permainan yang baik.

IDRBOLA said...

Berita Bola
Prediksi Bola
Situs Bola
Situs Bola Terbaik
Situs Casino Online
Situs Casino Terbaik
Situs Slot
Situs Slot Terbaik

situs judi online domino ceme pokerqq idn poker said...

I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a great information that is actually helpful. Good day!

Mia Khalifa said...

Semua jenis judi bola Taruhan Bola Online dibagi ke dalam setengah babak dan juga babak penuh. Kamu bisa pasang di kedua jenis tersebut atau pilih salah satu. Dari namanya saja kita bisa tahu bahwa setengah babak, taruhan berakhir pada saat turun minum. Jadi hasil taruhan akan lebih cepat bila kamu berjudi pada taruhan bola setengah babak. Bila kamu penasaran dengan judi bola online.

jasa website gembling said...

jasa seo indonesia

agen bola

Poker online
Poker Uang Asli

Prediksi Bola
Jadwal Bola
Agen Bola

poker qq online
pkv games

Services lock said...

Roswell Locksmith
Locksmith Roswell
we all in our Roswell, Ga we provide locksmith Services

situs agen judi online sbobet bola casino indonesia terpercaya said...

Great things you’ve always shared with us. Thanks.
agen ceme online terbaru